Italian Restaurant in Santa Fe New Mexico

Santa Fe is known for its rich Southwestern flavors, but the city also has a wonderful selection of Italian restaurants that bring the taste of Italy to New Mexico. From classic pasta and wood-fired pizza to creamy sauces, fresh ingredients, and delicious desserts, Italian dining in Santa Fe offers something for every food lover.

Whether you are looking for a cozy spot for a romantic dinner, a family-friendly restaurant, or anelegant place to enjoy authentic Italian flavors, Santa Fe has plenty of choices. In this guide, we will explore some of the best Italian restaurants in Santa Fe, their popular dishes, dining atmosphere, and what makes each one worth visiting.

Piccolino Italian Restaurant brings a warm and traditional Italian dining experience to Santa Fe. This family-owned and operated restaurant has a cozy, neighborhood feel that makes guests feel comfortable from the moment they walk in. With its classic checkered tablecloths, friendly service, and lively conversations among regulars, Piccolino creates the kind of atmosphere where a simple meal can feel like a gathering with family.

The restaurant focuses on family-style Italian food, making it a great choice for diners who enjoy hearty and comforting dishes. Its welcoming setting is perfect for casual lunches, relaxed dinners, and meals with family or friends. Rather than feeling formal or overly fancy, Piccolino offers a genuine local dining experience with the warmth and hospitality often associated with traditional Italian restaurants.

One of the things that makes Piccolino stand out is its strong family-run identity. The restaurant takes pride in serving its community while maintaining a friendly, personal atmosphere. Guests can enjoy Italian favorites in a relaxed setting while experiencing the charm of a restaurant that feels like a true neighborhood gathering place. Whether you are a Santa Fe local or visiting the city, Piccolino is a welcoming spot to enjoy a satisfying Italian meal.

Piccolino Italian Restaurant is conveniently located at the corner of Agua Fria Street and Siler Road in Santa Fe, New Mexico. Its location makes it an easy stop for locals and visitors looking for a relaxed Italian meal in the area. The neighborhood setting also adds to the restaurant’s welcoming, family-style atmosphere.

If you are planning to visit or want to confirm the location before heading out, you can contact the restaurant directly at (505) 471-1480. It is a good idea to call ahead for current hours, availability, or any other dining questions.

Piccolino’s menu brings together a wide range of Italian favorites, from fresh salads, soups, and appetizers to pasta, ravioli, pizza, calzones, baked dishes, chicken, veal, and seafood. With both classic recipes and unique specialties, the menu offers plenty of choices for families, casual diners, and Italian food lovers.

1. Salads

For a fresh start, Piccolino serves a variety of crisp and flavorful salads. Choices range from the classic Caesar and Italian Tomato Salad to Greek, Spinach, Capri, Goat Cheese, and Chopped Antipasto salads, with options like chicken, steak, cheese, olives, and fresh vegetables adding extra variety.

• Ceasar Salad ………. $9.99

Romaine lettuce, tossed with delicious Ceasar dressing, parmesan cheese, and homestyle croutons

• Chopped Italian ………. $12.99

Mixed greens, tomatoes, carrots, mozzarella, cucumbers, garbanzo beans, and zucchini, with Italian dressing

• Marc Salad ………. $18.99

Caesar Salad with breaded sesame chicken and angel hair pasta, tossed with Caesar dressing

• Spinach Salad ………. $10.99

Spinach, apricots, walnuts, and feta cheese, with balsamic vinaigrette

• Capri Salad ………. $11.99

Slices of fresh mozzarella, tomato and basil

• Goat Cheese Salad ………. $10.99

Mixed Greens, Goat Cheese, Tomato, Cucumber

• Greek Salad ………. $10.99

Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumber, kalamata olives, and feta cheese, with balsamic vinaigrette

• Italian Tomato Salad ………. $9.99

Tomatoes, cucumbers, and red onions tossed with Italian dressing over a bed of mixed greens

• Luigi Salad ………. $ market

Caesar salad tossed with artichoke hearts, roased peppers, and topped with filet mignon

• Chopped Antipasto ………. $13.99

Mixed greens, mozzarella, provolone, salami, peperoni, prosciutto, roasted peppers, artichoke hearts, garbanzo beans, carrots, and olives, with Italian dressing

• Side Of Garden Salad ………. $6.99

Mixed greens, carrots, mozzarella, tomatoes, cucumber, olives, and pepperoncini, choice of dressing. Add chicken or shrimp $7.99

2. Appetizers

Begin your meal with Piccolino’s tempting selection of Italian appetizers, from crispy Zucchini Fritti and Calamari Fritti to steamed mussels, fried mushrooms, and Mozzarella Marinara. For something more flavorful, the Garlic Bread Special comes topped with sun-dried tomatoes, mushrooms, garlic, and Marsala sauce.

• Sauteed Mushrooms Marsala ………. $8.99
• Zucchini Fritti ………. $8.99
• Steamed Mussels ………. $15.99
• Calamari Fritti ………. $14.99
• Mozzarella Marinara ………. $9.99
• Garlic Bread ………. $4.99
• Tri Fritti ………. $12.99

Zucchini, mozzarella, mushrooms

• Fried Mushrooms ………. $8.99
• Parmigiana Dip ………. $6.99
• Garlic Bread Special ………. $9.99

Topped with sundried tomatoes, mushrooms, and garlic and marsala sauce

3. Soups

Start your meal with a warm bowl of Minestrone, Pasta Faggioli, Stracciatella, or Tuscan Wedding Soup. Piccolino also offers Clam Chowder for seafood lovers, making the soup selection a nice mix of light vegetable options and hearty, filling flavors.

• Minestrone ………. $8.99

All vegetable soup

• Pasta Faggioli ………. $8.99

Penne pasta with cannellini beans and pancetta

• Stracciatella………. $8.99

Spinach, eggs, and chicken broth

• Tuscan Wedding………. $9.99

Vegetables, mini meat balls, and cannellini beans

• Clam Chowder ………. $12.99

4. Kids Menu

Piccolino’s Kids Menu offers simple and family-friendly favorites for younger diners. Choices include chicken strips, butter and cheese pasta, marinara pasta, Alfredo pasta, meat sauce pasta, chicken Alfredo, shrimp Alfredo, and pasta with meatballs, giving kids plenty of familiar Italian options.

• Chicken Strips ………. $9.99
• Pasta Butter and Cheese ………. $7.99
• Pasta Marinara ………. $8.99
• Pasta Alfredo ………. $10.99
• Pasta Meat Sauce ………. $10.99
• Chicken Alfredo ………. $11.99
• Shrimp Alfredo………. $13.99

• Pasta Meat Balls ………. $10.99

5. Baked Dishes

If you love cheesy, oven-baked Italian comfort food, this section is worth exploring. Piccolino serves hearty favorites such as Meat Lasagna, Manicotti, Cannelloni, Eggplant Parmigiana, Baked Ziti, and specialty options like Lasagna Bolloco with chicken, green chile, provolone, mozzarella, and Alfredo sauce.

• Meat Lasagna ………. $17.99

Ground beef, ricotta, parmesan

• Vegetariann Lasagna ………. $15.99

Eggplant, spinach, zucchini, ricotta, mozzarella

• Lasagna Bolloco ………. $18.99

Chicken, green chile, provolone, mozzarella, alfredo sauce

• Manicotti ………. $16.99

Filled with ricotta cheese, topped with marinara and mozzarella

• Canneloni ………. $18.99

Filled with ground beef, spinach, carrots, and ricotta, and topped with marinara and mozzarella

• Eggplant Parmigiana ………. $15.99

Layers of eggplant breaded, baked, and deep fried, topped with marinara and mozzarella

• Stuffed Eggplant ………. $17.99

Eggplant parmigiana with ricotta and herbs, rolled, and topped with marinara and cheese

• Grilled Eggplant ………. $16.99

Layers of grilled eggplant, topped with marinara and mozzarella

• Baked Ziti ………. $16.99

Ziti pasta with eggplant, ricotta, and marinara all baked together

• Chicken Chipotle Lasagna ………. $18.99

6. Sandwiches

• Chicken Parmigiana ………. $18.99

Breaded chicken with marinara and mozzarella cheese

• Spicy Sausage ………. $16.99

Sausage, marinara, and mozzarella cheese

• Spicy Meat Ball ………. $16.99

Meatball, marinara, and mozzarella cheese

• Baked Chicken ………. $18.99

Chicken, roasted red peppers, artichoke hearts, and pesto mayonnasie

• Veal Parmigiana ………. $19.99

Veal breaded and deep fried, marinara, and mozzarella cheese

• Eggplant Parmigiana ………. $16.99

Eggplant breaded, deep fried, and baked, with marinara and mozzarella cheese

• Yoga Sandwich ………. $16.99

Spinach, eggplant, roasted red peppers, and goat cheese

• Sub Sandwich ………. $16.99

Provolone cheese, salami, mortadella, pepperoni, lettuce, and tomato

• Tuna Melt ………. $16.99

Tuna, mayonnaise, tomatoes, celery

• Sausages and Peppers ………. $16.99

Sautéed peppers with onion and sausage

• Chicken Chipotle ………. $18.99

Chicken with creamy chipotle sauce

7. Pasta

Pasta lovers will find plenty to enjoy at Piccolino, with choices ranging from simple Marinara and Pomodoro to rich Alfredo, Bolognese, Carbonara, and specialty creations. The menu also includes vegetable-filled, cheesy, creamy, and meat-based pastas, so there is something for almost every craving.

• Marinara ………. $14.99
• Meat Balls ………. $16.99
• Meat Sauce ………. $16.99
• Angel Hair Pomodoro ………. $14.99
• Arabiatta ………. $14.99

Spicy marinara sauce

• Bolognese ………. $17.99

Meat sauce and mushrooms

• Alfredo ………. $15.99
• Michelangelo ………. $15.99

Mushrooms, spinach, and garlic

• Penne Rigatti ………. $17.99

Spinach, sun-dried tomatoes, and shitake mushrooms

• Olga’s Favorite ………. $16.99

Grilled eggplant, garlic, tomatoes, basil, and goat cheese

• Quatro Formaggio ………. $19.99

Four cheeses with broccoli and alfredo sauce

• Pasta Brooklyn ………. $18.99

Sausage, fresh tomatoes, basil, and garlic

• Tortellini Broccoli Pesto ………. $18.99

Cheese tortellini with creamy pesto and broccoli

• Carbonara ………. $17.99

Pancetta, eggs, choice of cream or no cream

• Primavera ………. $16.99

Sautéed vegetables, fresh tomatoes, basil, and garlic

• Amatricciana ………. $17.99

Sautéed onions, pancetta, fresh tomatoes, and cream

• Burina ………. $17.99

Sautéed pancetta, onions, and peas in a cream sauce

• Gnocchi Marinara ………. $15.99

8. Chicken

Served with pasta and veggies

• Chicken Alfredo ………. $20.99

Chicken pieces sautéed with garlic in a creamy alfredo sauce and tossed with pasta

• Chicken Chardonnay ………. $22.99

Chicken topped with mushrooms, pine nuts, and cream

• Chicken Penne ………. $20.99

Chicken pieces, sautéed with spinach, wine, tomatoes, lemon, and garlic, tossed with pasta

• Victor’s Favorite ………. $20.99

Sautéed chicken pieces, olives, garlic, eggplant, pine nuts, broccoli, and sundried tomatoes

• Chicken Dorothy ………. $20.99

Chicken pieces with pepperoncini, garlic, vegetables, sundried tomatoes

• Chicken Marsala ………. $20.99

Chicken breast topped with sautéed mushrooms, brown sauce

• Chicken Picatta ………. $20.99

Chicken breast topped with a lemon, butter, and caper sauce

• Chicken Piccolino ………. $20.99

Chicken pieces sautéed with butter, mushrooms, red & green bell pepper, white wine, with pasta

• Chicken Parmigiana ………. $20.99

Breaded and deep fried chicken topped with marinara and mozzarella cheese

• Chicken Florentine ………. $22.99

Chicken topped with sautéed spinach, shallots, marsala wine, and cheese

• Chicken Sesame ………. $20.99

Breaded chicken breast, deep fried, topped with lemon sauce

• Chicken Bolloco ………. $20.99

Chicken pieces, green chile, and creamy sauce

• Chicken A La Francese ………. $22.99

With artichoke hearts, mushrooms

• Chicken Bruno ………. $20.99

Chicken, mushrooms, and brown sauce

• Pasta Chipotle ………. $20.99

Chicken pieces with creamy chipotle sauce

• Chicken Mateo ………. $22.99

Chicken parmigiana with slice of eggplant

• Chicken Fra-Diavolo ………. $20.99
• Chicken Tetrazzini ………. $22.99
• Three Mushroom Chicken ………. $22.99

Chicken pieces, shitake, porcini, button mushrooms with a delicious creamy sauce tossed with pasta

9. Ravioli

• Cheese Ravioli ………. $14.99

Served with marinara sauce

• Chicken Ravioli ………. $16.99

Served with our pink sauce

• Crab Ravioli ………. $18.99

Served with our pink sauce

• Spinach Ravioli ………. $16.99

With alfredo or gorgonzola sauce

• Artichoke Ravioli ………. $16.99

Topped with spinach, tomatoes, and pine nuts

• Ravioli Di Mare ………. $21.99

Cheese ravioli topped with sautéed shrimp and Pomodoro sauce

10. Seafood

Served with pasta and veggies

• Gnocchi Di Mare ………. $21.99

Topped with shrimp and pomodoro sauce

• Pescatore ………. $26.99

Calamari, clams, steam mussels, shrimp and fish in a delicious steamy broth, served with pasta

• Shrimp Alfredo ………. $21.99

Shrimp sautéed with garlic, parmesan cheese, and cream sauce

• Shrimp Parmigiana ………. $21.99

Breaded and deep fried shrimp, topped with sauce and mozzarella

• Clams with Linguini ………. $22.99

Clams served in a steamy broth with red or white sauce

• Shrimp Fra Diavolo ………. $21.99

Shrimp sautéed with spicy marinara sauce over pasta

• Shrimp Scampi ………. $21.99

Sautéed shrimp with garlic, butter, paprika

• Shrimp Picatta ………. $21.99

Sautéed shrimp with a butter, lemon, caper sauce

• Shrimp Carcioffe ………. $23.99

Shrimp with artichoke hearts, capers, sundried tomatoes, wine sauce, tossed with pasta

• Linguini Provencal ………. $25.99

Jumbo scallops, shrimp, fresh tomatoes, scallions, butter and wine sauce

• Grilled Salmon ………. $24.99

Salmon topped with lemon, capers sauce

• Calamari Fra Diavolo ………. $21.99
• Shrimp Piccolino ………. $21.99
• Shrimp Bolloco ………. $21.99

Shrimp with green chile, and alfredo sauce

• Linguini and Mussels ………. $22.99

11. Veal

Served with pasta and veggies

• Veal Mateo ………. $25.99

Veal parmigiana topped with slice of eggplant parmigiana and cheese

• Veal Florentine ………. $24.99

Sautéed veal topped with spinach, cheese, scallions, and brown sauce

• Veal Milanese ………. $24.99

Veal, topped with butter, lemon sauce

• Veal Marsala ………. $24.99

With sautéed mushrooms, brown sauce

• Veal Parmigiana ………. $24.99
• Veal Picatta ………. $24.99
• Veal Saltimboca ………. $24.99

Topped with prosciutto, sage, brown sauce, and fontina cheese

• Veal Pizzaiola ………. $25.99

Topped with capers, olives, tomatoes, and cheese

• Veal Francese ………. $25.99

Veal topped with artichoke hearts, mushrooms, lemon, and white wine

We offer gluten free pasta substitutions $1.99 | full $2.99

12. Calzone

Piccolino offers several delicious calzone options, including Cheese, Spinach & Cheese, Special, BBQ, and Shrimp Calzones. These baked Italian favorites are a great choice for anyone who wants a hearty, cheesy meal with a flavorful filling.

• Spinach & Cheese Calzone ………. $16.99
• Special Calzone ………. $18.99
• Cheese Calzone ………. $15.99
• BBQ Calzone ………. $18.99

• Shrimp Calzone ………. $19.99

13. Pizza

All pizzas have mozzarella cheese

• Cheese Pizza ………. 10″ $9.99 | 16″ $18.99
• BBQ Chicken ………. 10″ $14.99 | 16″ $22.99
• Buffalo Chicken ………. 10″ $14.99 | 16″ $21.99

Chicken, green onions, spicy sauce, served with ranch

• Combo Pizza ………. 10″ $13.99 | 16″ $21.99

Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onion, bell pepper

• Real Meaty Delight ………. 10″ $13.99 | 16″ $21.99

Pepperoni, bacon, sausage, meatballs

• California Pizza ………. 10″ $13.99 | 16″ $18.99

Fresh veggies, goat cheese, sundried tomatoes

• Fernie Special ………. 10″ $14.99 | 16″ $23.99

Mozzarella cheese over pesto sauce with chicken

• Pizza Romano ………. 10″ $16.99 | 16″ $23.99

Pesto sauce, shrimp, feta cheese, roasted red peppers and mozzarella

• Greek Pizza ………. 10″ $12.99 | 16″ $18.99

Mozzarella, feta cheese, calamata olives, tomatoes, red onions, oregano

• Pizza Margherita ………. 10″ $9.99 | 16″ $15.99

Without sauce, with fresh tomatoes, mozzarella and basil

• Pizza Bolloco with Chicken ………. 10″ $15.99 | 16″ $21.99

With alfredo sauce, mozzarella, green chile, and chicken

• Pizza Bolloco with Shrimp ………. 10″ $16.99 | 16″ $24.99

With alfredo sauce, mozzarella, green chile, and shrimp

• Pizza Stagione ………. 10″ $12.99 | 16″ $19.99

Sundried tomatoes, artichoke hearts, black olives and pepperoncini

• Pizza Bianchi ………. 10″ $11.99 | 16″ $16.99

No sauce, mozzarella cheese, spinach, garlic

14. Pizza & Calzone Toppings

Pepperoni, green chile, meatballs, onions, pineapple, broccoli, olives, sausage, basil, fresh tomato, garlic, salami, canadian bacon, jalapeño, zucchini, mushrooms, eggplant, roasted peppers, green chile

• Standard Toppings ………. 10″ $1.99 | 16″ $2.50

15. Gourmet Toppings

• Pesto ………. 10″ $3.00 | 16″ $4.00
• Sun dried tomatoes ………. 10″ $3.00 | 16″ $4.00
• Goat cheese ………. 10″ $3.00 | 16″ $4.00
• Ricotta cheese ………. 10″ $3.00 | 16″ $4.00
• Anchovies ………. 10″ $3.00 | 16″ $4.00

• Artichoke hearts ………. 10″ $3.00 | 16″ $4.00

16. Add-On Items

Not available as à la carte

• Meat Ball (each) ………. $4.99
• Side of Alfredo or Pink Sauce ………. $4.00
• Meat Sauce ………. $4.00
• Chicken pieces ………. $8.99
• Shrimp (add on only) each ………. $2.49
• Side of Vegetables ………. $5.99
• Side of Roasted Garlic ………. $4.99
• Side of Oil and Garlic ………. $2.99
• Jumbo Scallops each ………. $3.00
• Salmon for Salads ………. $17.99

• Side of Sausage ………. $4.99

Santa Fe may be famous for its Southwestern cuisine, but its Italian restaurant scene is just as worth exploring. From comforting pasta, handmade-style ravioli, and cheesy baked dishes to fresh salads, seafood, pizza, and calzones, there are plenty of choices for Italian food lovers. Restaurants such as Piccolino have also earned a strong local reputation for their welcoming atmosphere and generous Italian comfort food.

Whether you want a casual family dinner, a classic pizza night, or a more elegant Italian meal, Santa Fe has an option for every occasion. Piccolino stands out for its extensive menu covering everything from chicken and veal to seafood, ravioli, baked dishes, pizza, and calzones, making it an especially versatile choice. With so many flavors and dining styles available, exploring the best Italian restaurants in Santa Fe is a delicious way to enjoy a different side of the city’s diverse food culture.

i. What are the best Italian restaurants in Santa Fe?

Santa Fe has several Italian restaurants offering pasta, pizza, ravioli, seafood, calzones, and classic Italian dishes. Piccolino is one option known for its family-style Italian food and extensive menu.

ii. What Italian food is popular in Santa Fe?

zopular choices include pasta, pizza, lasagna, ravioli, chicken Parmigiana, veal dishes, seafood pasta, and baked Italian specialties.

iii. Where can I find authentic Italian food in Santa Fe?

You can find traditional Italian flavors at local restaurants that focus on classic sauces, pasta dishes, fresh ingredients, and traditional Italian recipes.

iv. Does Piccolino Italian Restaurant serve pizza?

Yes. Piccolino offers several pizza options, including Cheese Pizza, Margherita, Greek Pizza, BBQ Chicken, Buffalo Chicken, and specialty pizzas.

v. Does Piccolino offer gluten-free pasta?

Yes. Gluten-free pasta substitutions are available for an additional charge, according to the restaurant’s menu.

vi. What pasta dishes are available at Piccolino?

The menu includes Marinara, Bolognese, Alfredo, Carbonara, Primavera, Amatricciana, Gnocchi Marinara, Tortellini Broccoli Pesto, and several specialty pasta dishes.

vii. Does Piccolino have seafood dishes?

Yes. Seafood choices include shrimp, mussels, clams, calamari, scallops, salmon, and fish, prepared in different Italian-style sauces.

viii. Are there vegetarian options at Italian restaurants in Santa Fe?

Yes. Many Italian restaurants offer vegetarian choices such as vegetable lasagna, eggplant Parmigiana, salads, vegetable pasta, Margherita pizza, and spinach ravioli.

ix. Does Piccolino have a kids’ menu?

Yes. Piccolino offers a kids’ menu with options such as chicken strips, butter and cheese pasta, marinara pasta, Alfredo pasta, chicken Alfredo, shrimp Alfredo, and pasta with meatballs.

x. What should I order at an Italian restaurant in Santa Fe?

For a classic experience, consider lasagna, ravioli, chicken Parmigiana, pizza, or a pasta specialty. Seafood lovers can try shrimp or seafood pasta, while those looking for something lighter can choose a fresh Italian salad.